Environmental Services — February 9, 2010

Closure of Pickering good for green energy; fixing Darlington wrong: Greenpeace

TORONTO, Feb. 9 /CNW/ - News reports indicating Ontario Power Generation (OPG) will not rebuild the four Pickering B nuclear reactors is another blow to the future of the Canadian nuclear industry and could provide an opportunity for expanding green energy, if the McGuinty government allows it, says Greenpeace.

"Choosing not to risk billions of dollars of public money rebuilding the Pickering reactors is the right decision although proposals to continue running Canada's most dangerous nuclear station as long as possible are a significant concern," said Shawn-Patrick Stensil, a nuclear specialist with Greenpeace. "In light of a decision to close Pickering, any decision to proceed with rebuilding the Darlington reactors would be folly and block the future expansion of green energy."

Greenpeace was responding to a Toronto Star report today that Ontario would eventually close the four Pickering B reactors due to high cost but would refurbish the Darlington reactors.

"Pickering's eventual closure would open up space on the electricity grid and give the McGuinty government the opportunity to increase its baseline targets for green energy by allowing green energy to replace Pickering," said Stensil. "Right now, nuclear energy blocks grid access for green energy and is the biggest long-term barrier to expanding green energy."

Greenpeace has long opposed the McGuinty government's nuclear plan to spend $26 billion to maintain nuclear at 50 per cent of Ontario's supply, which deprives green power of the grid space it needs to grow over the long-term. The McGuinty plan has underestimated nuclear costs, over-estimated the growth of electricity demand and given short shrift to green power and conservation.

"What Ontarians need to see now are the true costs of running Pickering past its end date and rebuilding Darlington, that will show the lack of wisdom in continuing to rely on nuclear plants," said Stensil. "We also need to see the safety studies to know what the risks will be."

Ontario suspended its purchase of two new CANDU reactors last summer when the cost topped $26 billion-$20 billion more than estimated and equal to the projected cost for the government's full plan of building new reactors and rebuilding all existing ones.

"Ontario's electricity planners got it wrong in 2006 when they told the McGuinty government it would cost just $6 billion to rebuild Pickering or replace it with a new reactor. Closing Pickering is the first step in turning around the Titanic. The McGuinty government must give the space opened up by Pickering to green energy developers," said Stensil.

A decision to not rebuild Pickering would also show things are going from bad to worse for the Canadian nuclear industry in 2010, which was plagued by cost over-runs, reactor cancellations and embarrassments in 2009. Unlike other reactor designs, CANDU reactors require extensive repairs at mid-life that make them uneconomical compared to other reactor designs. New Brunswick is now threatening to sue the federal government over the 16 month delay in repairing the Point Lepreau reactor.

"This news report foreshadows the death of CANDU. Who in his right mind would spend billions on a reactor that would cost even more billions to repair at midlife? CANDU can't compete against other expensive reactor designs let alone green energy," said Stensil.

While Greenpeace supports closing Pickering, it is concerned that the risks of accidents will increase if Ontario Power Generation were allowed to run the reactors longer than planned because it has decided it can't afford to spend billions needed to repair the station.

"Operating an aging reactor after its shut down date is like driving on bald tires. It might not be a problem in perfect driving conditions but do you want to take that risk?" said Stensil.

For further information: Alex Paterson, Media & Public Relations, (416) 524-8496; Shawn-Patrick Stensil, Energy Campaigner, (416) 884-7053

Print | Email

Latest Industry Press Releases

Updated 18:01 MDT, March 17, 2010  

Construction/Building

CEMATRIX Corporation Announces Appointment of a Vice President (2010-03-17)

Dessau raises $330,000 for Centraide (2010-03-17)

ADF Group Inc. announces the departure of its Chief Financial Officer (2010-03-17)

Black Diamond Group Limited Announces Closing of $25.33 Million Bought Deal Equity Financing (2010-03-17)

GTA REALTORS(R) Reporting March Mid-Month Housing Statistics (2010-03-17)

CEMATRIX Corporation Announces Appointment of New Director and Grant of Stock Options (2010-03-17)

GENIVAR Income Fund: Notice of 2009 Fourth Quarter and Year-End Results and Conference Call (2010-03-16)

CanWel Building Materials Fourth Quarter and 2009 Year End Earnings Release and Conference Call Notification (2010-03-16)

Bird Construction Income Fund announces Its Selection as the Preferred proponent for Alberta New Schools Project (2010-03-16)

Laird Electric secures $45 million of new projects in the Alberta oil sands (2010-03-16)

Global demand for equipment strong at Ritchie Bros. Edmonton auction (2010-03-15)

PARA PAINTS and Lowe's Announce Partnership (2010-03-15)

Vicwest Income Fund Announces Distribution for March 2010 (2010-03-15)

Mohawk Announces Cash Tender Offer for Up To $200,000,000 Aggregate Principal Amount of Its Outstanding 6.50% Senior Notes Due 2011 (2010-03-15)

European Energy Giants Increase Renewable Energy Portfolios, an Industrial Info News Alert (2010-03-14)

CMHC: Canada's Economic Action Plan Creates Jobs and Improves Housing on Reserve in Quebec (2010-03-12)

The Churchill Corporation Reports 2009 Financial Results (2010-03-12)

Brampton Brick Reports Results for the Fourth Quarter and Year Ended December 31, 2009 (2010-03-12)

Media Advisory: CMHC-Social Housing Renovation Announcement (2010-03-12)

Avis Aux Médias: SCHL-Annonce concernant la rénovation de logements sociaux (2010-03-12)

SCHL : Le Plan d'action économique du Canada crée des emplois et améliore les logements dans les réserves au Québec (2010-03-12)

Environmentally Friendly Soil Stabilizer Introduced to the Dominican Republic (2010-03-12)

Bird Construction Income Fund announces strong 2009 annual financial results and March and April 2010 distributions (2010-03-12)

Governments of Canada and Quebec Invest in New Affordable Housing in La Peche (2010-03-12)

Bird Construction Income Fund announces intention to convert to a dividend paying corporation and dividend policy (2010-03-12)

SNC-Lavalin refutes misinformation published on federal building contracts (2010-03-11)

Kids Crooked House Partners with Kinder Canada in Playhouse Giveaway (2010-03-11)

The Ultimate Design Tool for Segmental Retaining Walls Now Available From Allan Block(R) -- AB Walls 10 (2010-03-11)

Media Advisory: Social Housing Renovation Announcement (2010-03-11)

NorthGrid Solar Inc. opens regional offices in Ottawa and Sault Ste. Marie (2010-03-11)

Seacliff Awarded $8.4 Million Electrical Contract at Edmonton Clinic North (ECN) Bringing Total Work at ECN to $56.0 Million: Fourth Institutional Infrastructure Contract Win in 2010 (2010-03-11)

Waterfront Toronto unveils Underpass Park: A visionary design for a unique public park in the West Don Lands (2010-03-10)

SNC-Lavalin awarded contract for the Junin 2 Block in Venezuela (2010-03-10)

Public Storage Canadian Properties Announces Fourth Quarter 2009 Operating Results (2010-03-10)

MOST POPULAR STORIES
TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS

These projects have been selected from 378 projects with a total value of $3,604,490,024 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on yesterday.

TOWNHOUSE DEVELOPMENT

$63,800,000 Markham ON Prebid

RESIDENTIAL, RETAIL DEVELOPMENT

$50,000,000 Thorold ON Prebid

CONDOMINIUM BUILDING

$40,000,000 Etobicoke ON Negotiated

Daily Top 10

PROJECT NEWS BRIEFS